Wednesday 30 March 2011

Rough Cut Feedback

Front Cover

Good
  • Image
  • Colour scheme
  • Layout
  • Range of font sizes

Could be improved
  • 'Volume' should be in a more interesting font?
  • Variety of font sizes in weird places eg. "20 BEST TRACKS AND ALBUMS...."?
  • Looks more like a fashion magazine?
  • "LADY GAGA" blends in with the sea?
  • Improve barcode?

I will use these suggestions to improve my front cover however I would like to keep 'Volume' in a simple font but I will find a font that has a bit of an edge to it. Also the music magazines that I am using as inspiration almost look fashion like so I will keep my layout the same.

Contents Page

Good
  • Image
  • Colour scheme
  • Different fonts
  • Creative initial layout

Could be improved
  • Needs to be finished with the other images and text!
  • The text needs to stand out from the rocks in the background.
  • Not keen on the handwriting font?
  • Floating girl in the sky?
  • Is 'CONTENTS' too small, in the wrong font or in the wrong place?
  • Do music magazines have a whole fashion section?
  • Needs page number etc at bottom of page.

I think this was the weakest of my rough cuts as it wasn't as finished as the others. I will take all the advice onboard and improve all of things that was suggested, however in my existing magazines research I found that some music magazines do have a whole fashion section. This was confirmed to be important when I asked my target market what they would like to read and so I will keep the fashion section in.

Double Page Spread

Good
  • Image
  • Layout
  • Colour scheme
  • Quote
  • Font

Could be improved
  • Make "KATY PERRY" bigger and move the quote closer together and lower down? This will make it easier to see when printed out.
  • Need to finish article.
  • Check grammar and make sure words aren't split up on to different lines?
  • Try and get the question and answer in the same column?
  • The dots are quite random?
  • Needs page number etc at bottom of page.

I will improve all of these things on my double page spread.